The Truth About Executive Coaching: What It Is, What It Isn't, and Why Founders Need It

"The best coaches aren’t the ones with all the answers. They’re the ones who ask the right questions." — Eric Schmidt (Former CEO of Google)

The word "coach" is often thrown around loosely, leading to confusion. The context within business and sports can further blur the lines. Before diving into what coaching truly is, let's clarify what it is not. If you're looking for any of the following services, coaching at Win the War may not be the right fit—but our consulting team may be able to assist you.

Coaching vs Guru

Social media is flooded with self-appointed "coaches" showcasing luxury cars, mansions, and testimonials of success. They promise to take you from point A to point B, positioning themselves as the shortcut to success. In reality, most of them are functioning as consultants or motivational speakers, not coaches.

If they were labeled as consultants, you’d scrutinize their background, ask for industry-specific success metrics, and expect them to analyze your business and provide a tailored improvement plan. Instead, many of these so-called coaches are selling generic, pre-packaged programs with no scientific or industry-backed approach. Real consulting—which we offer—requires a deep dive into a company’s strategies and must be based on proven best practices. The difference? These gurus are selling a one size fits all methodology, not coaching.

Coaching vs Consulting

Consulting provides expert advice and a tailored prescription for business improvement. If a consultant claims they can diagnose your business problems in a single call, you may be dealing with a guru rather than a true consultant. Real consulting is strategic and customized—there is no one-size-fits-all approach.

Coaching, on the other hand, is not about giving you answers. In coaching, you hold the answers; the coach’s role is to help you uncover them. Consulting is THEM-focused (they bring the answers). Coaching is YOU-focused (you bring the answers).

Coaching vs Mentorship/Teaching

Many believe coaching means finding someone who has already achieved success in your field and asking them questions. That’s mentorship, not coaching.

Mentors and teachers provide guidance and education based on their experiences. Having a mentor is invaluable, and you should seek out multiple mentors with different perspectives. However, mentorship is fundamentally about learning from someone else's journey, while coaching is about developing your own insights and solutions.

Coaching vs Therapy

Let’s be clear: coaching is not therapy. While coaching may feel therapeutic, it is not a substitute for professional mental health care. Therapy focuses on diagnosing and healing past traumas and mental health issues, while coaching is future-focused, centering on goals, performance, and personal development.

A good coach may help a client recognize when therapy is necessary, but coaching itself is not therapy. If your coach is heavily focused on your past and trying to "diagnose" issues, they are crossing into a domain that requires clinical training and licensure.

“Advice is dangerous. You can take the wrong advice from the right person or the right advice from the wrong person." — Naval Ravikant

So What is Coaching

The International Coaching Federation (ICF) defines coaching as:

"Partnering with clients in a thought-provoking and creative process that inspires them to maximize their personal and professional potential. The process of coaching often unlocks previously untapped sources of imagination, productivity, and leadership."

Coaching is about creating a space for exploration and discovery. A coach helps you examine challenges by asking open-ended questions, challenging assumptions, and reframing perspectives. The smartest person in the room during a coaching session should be you—the founder. You know your business best. Coaching helps remove mental blocks, build confidence, and develop clarity so you can take more effective action.

Unlike mentorship, coaching is not about giving you the answer—it’s about helping you find your own. The greatest value coaching provides is a neutral, judgment-free space where you can discuss challenges without worrying about how your investors, team, or advisors might react.

What is Executive Coaching?

Executive coaching focuses on leadership development, decision-making, and strategic thinking. It is often geared towards founders, CEOs, and senior leaders looking to improve their ability to manage teams, communicate effectively, and drive company growth. Executive coaching helps founders:

·       Develop a clearer strategic vision

·       Improve decision-making under pressure

·       Manage and inspire high-performing teams

·       Balance short-term execution with long-term planning

What is Performance Coaching?

Performance coaching centers on optimizing productivity, time management, and goal setting. This type of coaching benefits founders who struggle with execution and consistency. Key elements of performance coaching include:

·       Creating personal and professional routines for success

·       Eliminating distractions and improving focus

·       Overcoming procrastination and mental blocks

·       Enhancing accountability and follow-through

What is Life Coaching?

Life coaching helps founders balance their personal and professional lives, build resilience, and maintain well-being. Founders often struggle with burnout, imposter syndrome, or personal relationships as they scale their companies. Life coaching can help with:

·       Managing stress and avoiding burnout

·       Strengthening personal relationships while leading a company

·       Developing emotional intelligence and self-awareness

·       Finding fulfillment beyond business success

"Startups don’t die because they run out of money. They die because founders run out of energy." — Justin Kan (Twitch, Atrium)

Key Coaching Tools & Techniques

Identifying and Overcoming Limiting Beliefs

Many founders operate with unconscious mental barriers that hold them back. Coaching helps uncover these beliefs and challenge them. Common limiting beliefs include:

·       "I’m not ready to raise capital yet."

·       "I need to have all the answers before I hire a team."

·       "Failure means I’m not cut out for this."

By recognizing and reframing these beliefs, founders can move forward with greater confidence.

Reframing Techniques

Reframing is a powerful tool to shift perspective and open up new possibilities. A coach may help a founder turn:

·       "I failed at my first startup" into "I gained valuable experience that will help me succeed next time."

·       "My team isn’t listening to me" into "How can I communicate more effectively to inspire my team?"

Powerful Questioning

A great coach doesn’t give answers—they ask the right questions to help founders uncover insights. Examples include:

·       "What would success look like in this situation?"

·       "What’s stopping you from taking action right now?"

·       "How does this decision align with your long-term vision?"

Are You Ready for Coaching?

There’s a common misconception that coaching is only for later-stage companies with significant revenue or funding. This couldn’t be further from the truth. Coaching can be incredibly valuable at any stage, but the real question is: Are you in the right mindset to benefit from coaching?

Coaching at early stages often focuses on personal effectiveness, managing the chaos of fundraising, structuring your MVP development, dealing with investor rejection, refining hiring strategies, and gathering customer feedback. There are no universal answers to these challenges—every founder must find their own unique path. Coaching doesn’t provide ready-made solutions; instead, it equips you with the tools to unlock your own best answers.

Green Flags: You're Ready for Coaching If...

  • You’re Open to Feedback: You recognize that fresh perspectives can help you grow and are willing to hear insights that challenge your assumptions.

  • You’re Willing to Self-Reflect: You focus on what you can learn from every experience instead of assigning blame.

  • You’re Committed to a Process: You understand that improvement requires sustained effort—there is no magic bullet.

  • You Can Dedicate the Time: Coaching sessions typically take an hour a week, but the real work happens outside of sessions.

  • You Recognize That Personal Growth Fuels Business Growth: Your ability to lead effectively directly impacts your startup’s success.

Red Flags: You Might Not Be Ready for Coaching If...

  • You Expect the Coach to “Fix” Your Problems: If you think a coach will hand you a solution rather than help you develop your own, coaching may not be right for you.

  • You’re Closed Off to New Perspectives: If you reject alternative viewpoints or become defensive when your thinking is challenged, coaching may not provide much value.

  • You’re Looking for a Quick Fix: Coaching isn’t about short-term hacks—it’s about long-term transformation.

  • You’re Unwilling to Be Vulnerable: The most valuable coaching engagements happen when founders are open about their challenges and willing to explore deeper issues.

"The best founders don’t just want feedback—they crave it." — Paul Graham (Y Combinator)

Final Note About Industry Leaders

A common misconception is that a coach must have direct industry experience to be effective. However, look at professional sports—many of the best coaches in the NFL never had successful playing careers. Some never even played at a competitive level. Coaching, whether in sports or business, is about elevating performance and getting the best out of individuals and teams.

Similarly, startup founders often assume that a coach with a background in startups is the best fit. However, a coach who has built a startup may be limited by their own experiences and biases. Great coaching comes from an unbiased, open perspective that helps founders see challenges in new ways. By stepping outside of the typical Silicon Valley framework, coaching can provide unique insights that founders might not get from someone embedded in the startup ecosystem.

Final Thoughts

Executive coaching for founders isn’t about handing you a playbook—it’s about equipping you with the tools and mindset to succeed on your own terms. The best startup founder coaching will challenge you to think bigger, push past your limits, and take confident, strategic action.

Key Takeaways:

  1. Coaching is about self-discovery, not advice. Unlike consulting or mentorship, coaching helps you uncover your own solutions, not follow someone else’s.

  2. Great founders invest in their own growth. The most successful startup leaders understand that personal development directly impacts business success.

  3. Coaching is a process, not a quick fix. Long-term results come from continuous reflection, action, and commitment to growth.

If you’re ready to step up your leadership, navigate challenges with greater clarity, and make meaningful progress in your business, now is the time to invest in yourself.

🚀 Schedule a consultation with us today at Win the War and start transforming your leadership journey.

Next
Next

Navigating Early Challenges: Why Every Founder Should Consider a Coach